Your Watchlist

Apps

© 2026 Parcl Labs

Back

In single-family rental markets with 250+ active portfolio listings, Parcl analyzed vacancy rates using only properties with proven rental history—revealing where tenant placement is faltering even among homes that have previously leased without issue. Once again, Florida stands out for all the wrong reasons. As we’ve detailed in prior reports, the state continues to struggle with oversupply, softening demand, and elevated vacancy.

Florida Dominates the Top Ten

Florida accounts for six of the ten highest-vacancy metros in the country.

Punta Gorda (5.07%) and Cape Coral–Fort Myers (5.06%) top the list, followed by:

  • Homosassa Springs — 4.66%

  • North Port–Sarasota–Bradenton — 4.29%

  • Naples–Marco Island — 4.29%

  • Jacksonville — 4.11%

Collectively, these markets reflect a clear pattern: Florida’s SFR oversupply pressures remain acute. Even properties with successful rental track records are now sitting vacant at 2–3x above typical institutional thresholds.

The Southeast Also Feels the Pressure

Outside Florida, elevated vacancy is spreading across the region.

  • Atlanta (4.17%), the largest SFR market in the U.S. with 136,211 investor-owned homes, continues to post above-normal vacancy despite its diversified economy.

  • Macon, GA (4.12%) and Spartanburg, SC (4.12%) also land in the top ten—evidence that affordability constraints are increasingly limiting tenant absorption across the broader Southeast.

What This Means

Vacancy rates in the 4–5% range for historically rented homes represent real revenue leakage for investors—especially as fixed operating costs remain elevated. The data signals a structural shift:

  • Pandemic-era migration surges have fully normalized.

  • Supply additions in Sun Belt markets are outpacing sustainable tenant demand.

  • Operators now face strategic decisions: rent concessions, higher marketing spend, or selective disposition.

Chart 1: Florida—once the SFR industry’s growth engine—now illustrates the risks of aggressive expansion without matching long-term demand fundamentals.

Uploaded image

SFR portfolios are more transparent than ever utilizing Parcl's proprietary Portfolio Ownership Mapping capabilities. Every property in every portfolio coming in just a couple of weeks. The waitlist goes live December 1st.

Authors

Jesus Leal

Jesus Leal

Trevor Bacon

Follow Us for More